A Room With a View by E.M. Forster

Book Cover, courtesy of LibrarythingE.M. Forster’s A Room With a View is an unexpected romance. I’m not just talking about the plot itself, which revolves around the coming of age and sensual awakening of a young young British woman during her first visit to Italy. By romance, I’m talking about the act of reading the novel itself: I unexpectedly fell in love with the story. You see, I never felt any passion for English novels before. I’ve not ignored them completely, having read about 15 novels so far but considering the vastness of British literature, that number is frankly pathetic.

The usual turn-off for me are the characters, mainly because I find many of them emotionally inaccessible. Maybe that’s too harsh a description but I can’t think of anything else. I don’t see restraint as a necessarily bad thing (see my fondness for Hemingway’s stories), but when I have to make too much effort to empathize with protagonists, I tend to lose interest. I felt this way with the works of John LeCarre, John Fowles, even Oscar Wilde (technically Irish, but let’s not quibble). Virginia Woolf’s To the Lighthouse is the exception. But for that novel, it was the exquisite language of that novel that won me over, and not the people.

E.M. Forster makes it easy for you to care about his characters. They are all so… vulnerable, all of them fumbling for their own versions of an ideal life. Some of them succeed without even realizing it. I didn’t expect to like the main character, Lucy Honeychurch, or even care about her unemployed, Italy-vacationing, upper-middle class existence. Yet I did. My favorite character is Mr. Emerson, George’s father. Such fanciful notions on philosophy and existence, an old man I’d *love* to listen to all day. But then, I do have a weakness for talkative old men.

There is so much to be said about Forster’s breezy, evocative style. He vividly depicted Florence at the height of spring, the English countryside’s bright summers giving way to the frostiness of autumn. I also take it as a sign of great cosmic irony, having read it when Manila’s weather was at its most humid and oppressive. Heh.

I’m still getting the hang of this writing about books thing. I felt like I rambled too much of non-important musings and not enough description of the book itself. Also, I’ll post my list for the By the Decade Reading Challenge tomorrow.

4 Comments on “A Room With a View by E.M. Forster”


  1. [...] 1900’s – A Room With a View, E.M. Forster [...]

  2. Thomas Otto Says:

    I am glad you loved this book. I get a good feeling just thinking about E.M. Forster’s books. Most, if not all of them, seem to be about breaking free of society’s expectations.

    And this may be sacreligious to say this, but if you haven’t seen the Merchant Ivory film version from the mid-1980s you really must. I think it is one of the few instances where book and movie are equal masterpieces.


  3. [...] of the Baskervilles (Raidergirl3) The Lighthouse at the Edge of the World, Jules Verne (Melissa) A Room With a View, E.M. Forster (Kristel) Sister Carrie, Theodore Dreiser (Melissa) The Wind in the Willows, Kenneth Grahame (1908) [...]

  4. hmks Says:

    This is one of my favorite books (my other is “The Age of Innocence” by Wharton). I agree with your assessment of English characters seeming emotionally inaccessible, but that’s is one of those English stereotypes that is true. The English aren’t the world’s best emotionally connected group of people, but they have managed to produce some of the world’s greatest writers and poets. Perhaps there is something to be said for that – perhaps people who suppress their emotions have to in turn get them out on the page. Hmmm… someone should write a paper on that… :-)


Comment: